music education

Some Baffling Baermann

A clarinet teacher was recently in touch with a rather interesting query over a marking and a flat in my edition of the Carl Baermann Variations Sentimentales (No. 74 in More Graded Studies for Clarinet Book 2 published by Faber Music) and presently set on ABRSM’s Grade 8 syllabus.

This particular study comes from Baermann’s Clarinet School Op 63, first published in 1864 taking the clarinet player from what was considered a beginner in those days (the very first exercise uses virtually the entire range of the instrument!) via a systematic journey through all the keys (with related scales, exercises, and studies).

I was fairly certain that I hadn’t made any errors in my Faber edition but nevertheless decided to undertake some detective work. The first query concerned a staccato marking under a slur (found in the first upbeat of bars 4, 8 and 12).

In both my edition and the 1918 edition of the Baermann Complete Method published by Carl Fischer, the note appears as follows:

Baermann Complete Method, 1918

In performances this suggests a slight separation of the two B-flats.

I decided to investigate the original 1864 edition published by Offenbach am Main. Baermann, in fact, places a dot over both the B-flats:

Clarinett – (Schule, 1864)

So, the question is, was it a deliberate edit by Gustav Langenus in 1918 to miss out the second dot or an error in the typesetting?  

I have followed Langenus in my edition because, in my opinion, as presumably in Lengenus’, a separation between the first and second beat (of the full bar after the upbeat) is not appropriate for either the phrasing or character of this music. Also, the following variations don’t indicate a separation of the first and second beats, and to separate these beats would interrupt the flow of the music. The other query concerns a G-flat in bars 44 and 59 in the second variation.

Baermann Complete Method, 1918 - Variation 2, bar 44

Neither Langenus in his 1918 edition, nor Baermann in 1864 indicate that this G-flat should be naturalised in its second appearance in both those bars. The original edition was published with a piano accompaniment but sadly these are rarely used today, with the whole set of studies usually played unaccompanied. In investigating the harmony in the piano accompaniment, the G-flat is clearly intended throughout the bar; there is no inference for a change back to G-natural.

Bar 44 with piano accompaniment (showing clarinet part in concert pitch)

In fact, the G-flat, when it returns in the third beat is an entirely acceptable passing note, however as an unaccompanied piece, you may prefer the sound of a G-natural on its second appearance. Thus, maintaining the G-flat or altering it to a G-natural both work in performance. It’s entirely up to you!

Assuming that most music is correct when you see it in print (from first editions onwards) it’s probably best to follow the printed score. There are of course exceptions to this ‘rule.’  Performance markings (marks of attack, articulation and dynamics) were fairly sparsely used until the late Classical and early Romantic periods. Weber was well known for leaving many of these choices to his performers. For example much of what you might see in today’s editions are often editorial. So, using good taste and making informed choices is quite acceptable, particularly when it comes to the interpretation of those markings in music of this period. Making changes to pitch is more questionable, though it’s impossible to know whether, just occasionally, a composer might have made a mistake, forgotten to correct an accidental… or maybe simply ran out of ink at the crucial moment…

Can slow practice ever be exciting?

Now there’s a question to ponder…

Most pupils equate slow with boring. But if we can help those pupils to enjoy a bit more active engagement with their practice, we can begin to change this age-old attitude.

For many, practice is done with the brain remaining in a fairly low gear, with brain power only just in the on-position, playing through pieces or singing songs, possibly correcting the odd mistake along the journey. 

Energy levels tending to stay quietly and pleasantly subdued. For others, maybe practice is more active – making connections, and being more imaginative and creative.

For those who might be having a go at introducing more Mini Outcomes and Personal Bests into their practice, they might be finding that it can actually generate a lot of fun and cause a real rise in those energy levels.

So what about slow practice?

Once we’ve programmed a computer to do something, it will always do it. As we practise, we need to programme our brains in a similar way. If we do this programming carefully, the consequent progress will be significantly enhanced.  Here’s a thought:

Slow Practice – Fast Brain

As we are carry out our next activity let’s put our brain into high gear. Maybe the decision is to play a four-bar phrase (we often simply set off to play too many bars).  Choose a slow pulse – it’s not slow really, it just means that it will take longer to get to the next pulse or beat – the next event.  But in the time we’ve given ourselves in the journey to that next beat we can think! We can do a lot of fast and really focussed thinking on what we are about to do to get to that next beat successfully.

So what might we be thinking about, and what might we be working out (fast!) in that extra moment we now have?

  • Which finger is going to play the next note?  Is my hand shape correct to play it?

  • Exactly how will I make the change of hand position for the next note?

  • Are the correct fingers ready and energised to play the next chord?

  • Which part of the bow should I be in?

  • Exactly what am I going to do to the bow speed? 

  • What will I do to make a change of dynamic?

  • How will I control the staccato/legato/accent?

  • Can I hear the pitch of the next note really accurately before I sing it?

There are literally endless aspects of playing or singing we can prepare as we get ready to move to the next beat. By making that preparation, whatever it is we have to do on that next beat – we will certainly do it better!

Maybe we then  repeat those four bars.  But let’s not repeat them mindlessly.  In the extra moment we now have we can polish our previous thought and action or we can consider a different thought in perfecting the journey to the next beat.  We can repeat the phrase many times, each time with a different thought in our active minds.

We are carefully and effectively programming our brain. And once programmed, we will find that, like any computer, our brain will begin to do the job on its own and do it accurately and with understanding.  Then we can begin to shorten the time it takes to get to the next beat (‘play faster’).  Our brains have got it. Putting the next thing sooner (‘playing faster) is no problem for our well-programmed brain.  And, because of this thorough preparation, we are then able to apply it to other similar situations.  Our learning is advancing in every possible way.

Similarly, when we are preparing our Mini Outcomes the outcomes will be even more effective with occasional slow practice.  And that will ultimately cause even more success in our Personal Bests.

We are actively engaging our minds.  And when minds are actively engaged they don’t get bored! Slow practice is far from boring – it’s quite the opposite. Slow practice is exciting!

Developing a new approach to music practice

In the previous post we talked about encouraging pupils to have maybe two shorter practice sessions in a day rather than one longer one.

As part of our challenge to begin changing our pupils’ practice mindsets, let’s begin to challenge them with some questions they need to ask themselves as they set out on their short practice sessions:

  • Why am I going to do this?

  • How am I going to do it?

Then they devise an activity that fits either the Personal Best (PB) or the Mini Outcome (MO) models. They do the activity.

  • I did it…

  • What shall I do next?

  • What have I achieved?

Paul Harris april 2020.png

Let’s take one of the potentially less glamorous areas for practice – a scale – and see what might be possible…

Practice No 1

Minuet in G is my new piece. So, as it is in G,  I’m going to begin by practising the scale of G. (Other ingredients are staccato and p.)

1st activity I’ll play one octave of G up and down quite slowly, with even rhythm (noting the speed on metronome). (MO)

2nd activity:  I’ll play it staccato. (MO)

3rd activity:  I’ll play 2 bars of really well controlled staccato notes in a row. (PB)

4th activity I’ll find two bars (that are made up of a staccato scale passage) and play them with even rhythm and really crisp staccato. (MO)

Reflection What have I achieved? I’m aware I’ve made some progress.

Practice No 2

1st activity I’ll play that scale again one notch faster (or maybe 2!). (PB)

2nd activityI’ll clap the rhythm of the whole piece very steadily*. (MO)

3rd activity:  I’ll work on that 2-bar phrase again to get it really well controlled and with a dance-like character. (MO)

4th activityI’ll play it again as softly as I can. (PB)

Reflection:  I’m aware of my progress (pupil begins a chart for scale tempo) and looking forward to my next practice!

*Wasn’t sure of the rhythm in bar 6, so will ask teacher.

So, in one day’s practice they’ve achieved five Mini Outcomes and three Personal Bests and have one question for the teacher. Of course, the sessions won’t actually go exactly like that, and pupils will need a bit of help and encouragement. In lessons, talk equally about the practice activities alongside your more usual lesson feedback.  Use questions like:

  • How might you practise that?

  • What activity might you do next?  

And always ask for a report on the Mini Outcomes (MOs) and Personal Bests (PBs), suggesting one or two new ones from time to time (see last post!).

All being well, an exciting new kind of approach is brewing. An activity-based approach, driven by short, clear, fun, understandable, mildly challenging and imaginative activities. In time it will grow and a whole a new attitude towards practice will have developed.

Personal Bests and Mini Outcomes: Some thoughts on your pupils’ practice in these unprecedented times

Naturally the first necessity for all of us in these in these exceptional times is a combination of looking after ourselves and those close to us, with an eye on moving forwards towards a better future.

For many younger folk, especially those who would normally be living a highly structured life based around the routine that school or college provide, it is all very strange and different.

But, looking from a more positive perspective, for those who love their music and are learning to play or sing this time can serve as an opportunity to help them progress on an unprecedented scale. 

Home+music+paulharristeaching.jpg

So, let’s get our pupils practising! Give them some routine, normality and the potential for deep and meaningful engagement, in a world where the usual expectations have, for a while, been removed.

Practice… it’s a heavily loaded word! I’ve never quite known why (for some, anyway) it’s associated with negative thoughts. Let’s set about changing that.

 

******

First there are some background principles we need to take into account:

  • Young people are interested in NOW

  • The process needs to be enjoyable

  • The practical and immediate relevance needs to be clear

  • No one particularly wants to do ‘chores’

And also some clear guidelines in how to create the perfect psychological environment.  The practice needs to be:

  • Understandable and engaging

  • Appropriately challenging

  • Fun

  • Rewarding

  • Imaginative

GettyImages-1134468917.jpg

Whether you’re a computer gamer or not, there are certain lessons we can learn from the world of video games. 

  • The process itself is diverting, engaging, focussing and fun

  • There is a clear sense of direction: I know what I’m supposed to be doing and why

  • The progress is clear: Today I went up 20 (or maybe 200 or 2000) levels



So, how can we apply all this to help our pupils practise?

Put simply, they need to:

  • Plan for progress, and

  • See that progress when it happens

Practice is often too vague and so pupils simply play/sing through pieces and songs, maybe correcting a few obvious errors along the way.  There’s not much fun in this.  We need to help pupils make a mental shift to more dedicated and goal-orientated practice, rather than filling up time with the brain only just in gear.

 

******

We therefore want to encourage pupils to organise their practice with two particular types of activity in mind:

Personal Bests

(which are generally more directed towards technique)

and

Mini Outcomes

(which are generally more musically based)

Personal Bests are either how…

  • …evenly

  • …loudly

  • …softly

  • …cleanly

  • …confidently

  • …beautifully

  • …speedily

  • …slowly 

  • …expressively

…can I do this thing, or play this note / phrase / passage?

It best applies to a specific technical aspect: the control of a new note; the control of the bow on a string crossing; the crispness of a staccato note or the control of an ornament… the list is endless. 

Or PBs are concerned with How many…

  • …times can I tongue this note in 10 seconds?

  • …times can I play G major remembering the F sharp?

  • …times can I repeat this bar with perfect control?

  • …connections can I make within this piece?

  • …pieces/songs can I perform confidently at the moment?




Mini Outcomes are little challenges. They are concerned with Can I…? and How can I…?

  • …improve the control of that staccato note?

  • …play the first bar/last bar/any bar really beautifully?

  • …keep my bow really straight in this bar?

  • …play/sing this section with really vivid dynamic contrasts?

  • …play this scale with really crisp staccato?

  • …memorise the first 5 notes/octave of this scale?

In other words, they are asking the pupil to think: Can I do this thing like this…? 

******

As our pupils are making their lists of PBs or MOs, we also want to encourage them to think:

  • Why am I doing this?

  • How am I going to do it?

  • What is the result?

Given that there is probably more time available now for practice, you could suggest that pupils practise a number of times a day but each session is quite short and is aimed towards some very specific outcomes. Practice then become a series of Personal Bests and Mini Outcome activities.  Maybe two or three of each. This ticks all the boxes as set out above – it’s understandable and engaging, appropriately challenging, fun, rewarding and imaginative!

In time, pupils will become much better at creating a more positive practice mindset and a more practical way of using the time.

In tandem with this we need to teach pupils how to set up and react constructively and productively to what they do. They will need to look at the music to be practised, think, analyse and ask themselves lots of questions.

That could go a little like this:

In this practice session I’m going to work at this section of this piece, which has some staccato. I want to improve the staccato control and improve my staccato speed.

Mini Outcomes:  Work at staccato. Can I play them more crisply? How can I play them more crisply?  Can I play this bar of staccatos evenly?

Personal Bests: Can I play a really crisp staccato note? How many crisp staccato notes can I play in 10 seconds?  Last PB on staccato was four beats of semiquavers at crotchet = 60.  Today I’ll try crotchet = 61… or five beats at crotchet = 60.  

By the end of that session a lot of very focussed work will have been done.  If something hasn’t been understood, instead of getting frustrated, encourage the pupil to note it down as a question for the next lesson.

GettyImages-974341714.png

Measuring progress

The realisation of a Personal Best is a clear indication of progress.

The successful completion and accomplishment of a Mini Outcome is also an indication of progress.

Pupils have made progress and are aware of the progress they’ve made in each practice session.

It’s very motivating.

******

Do let me know how you get on if you are able to encourage your pupils to try these ideas.

I’ll be in touch over the next few days and weeks with some more practical ideas to help you inspire your pupils with their music practice and learning at home…

 





Have you 'got' it?

It’s great when students get things. That happy moment when the penny drops, the eyes light up and we become enveloped in that warm glow of satisfaction knowing that our teaching has been successful.

But then, oh dear.

Our students return the following week and that new fingering or rhythm seems to have departed from their minds. What they had (and please forgive the usage) gotten, they seem now to have for-gotten. Interestingly, to forget tends to imply that the information isn’t entirely irrecoverable. In saying we’ve forgotten, we generally mean “I can’t remember it at the moment, but it will probably come back.” And that may indeed be the case. 

But it’s often not the case.

I love a particular word that disappeared from common usage many centuries ago. And that word is un-get. This is often what happens after we teach our students something new for the first time. The fact is, it hasn’t been temporarily forgotten. Whatever that thing was that they had got, they have now un-got.  It is irretrievable. It has completely gone! 

But that’s okay, let’s not worry about it. Instead, and with good humour, we simply need to teach it again, to encourage them to re-get it! And how do we do this?

The secret is to teach it again from other angles.

One great way to achieve this is by using the Simultaneous Learning Musical Map of the World (available to download free here) which will give you lots of ideas for teaching the matter in question in different ways and contexts that are linked to the piece you are working on. The key is to alter the order of steps that led up to that teaching/learning moment.  Simply make the appropriate connections in a different order.

This will help us discover what hasn’t quite been understood and is therefore preventing our student from properly getting it. Maybe they are not playing a phrase staccato – although they did last week. The reason they haven’t entirely got it yet might be aural – they are not hearing the staccato in their musical ear – or it could be a technical issue, or maybe it’s to do with dynamic levels or some aspect of their technique.  Let’s explore all these possibilities, vary the order in which we do so and, all being well, our student will eventually get with less likelihood of subsequently for-getting or indeed un-getting.

And so here is my ‘re-’ declining of the verb to get:

I get – which happens sometimes. But often… 

I for-get – which is possible. But more probably…

I un-get – which is more likely!  But that’s okay, because with a good teacher to reinforce the idea…

I re-get! – and it stays!

And that can’t help but make us all feel so much happier…

Paul will be presenting “Are your students really learning?” at the Music & Drama Education Expo, London on 6 March 2019.

Now you're learning!

Considering the optimum environment for effective learning.

Successful learning is something we would like all our pupils to experience. Let’s consider three factors that are central to bringing this about.

As teachers we like to be in control. We know what’s best. We know what works. We have all the answers (or most of them anyway).

IMG_8486.jpg

But for really effective teaching and learning we also have to go with the flow. Everyone we teach is different. Recognising each individual’s needs, harmonising with their learning speed, acknowledging each response and then responding back appropriately are all key aspects of truly successful teaching and learning. So, be in control… but do also go with the flow. We can balance these two life forces, and applying this balance when you are teaching is crucial. In practice, and in general terms, we do need to know where we’re going with each pupil and have a clear idea of a lesson’s path. But we also need to be constantly adapting. We may well have an agenda, but it must be very flexible. Teach the pupil through the music and the instrument.

We also need to be patient. And so do our pupils and their parents! Appropriate patience in teaching and learning has a lot to do with expectation: learning to manage expectation and being as realistic as possible is so important. Pupils and parents are often impatient, usually because their expectations are unrealistic. If we can bring realistic targets to all teaching and learning situations we will really begin to instil happy and contented learning.

Finally, empathy. In my opinion, the most important quality of the Virtuoso Teacher is an ability to communicate. For really effective communication to take place we have to do our best to understand deeply the person or persons with whom we are communicating.

“When our pupils feel they are understood then they can begin to relax into really productive and secure learning.”

Here, we must do our best to determine their interests, their learning speed, their level of motivation, their natural energy levels and what makes them tick musically – all without them actually realising! When our pupils feel they are understood then they can begin to relax into really productive and secure learning.

So, be in control but go with the flow; set realistic and understandable targets to create a patient approach and empathise with your pupils. You will be delighted to see your pupils becoming truly happy and effective learners.

The Double O Mindset

Simultaneous Learning is rooted in a ‘can-do’ world where activities are always pro-actively set up to flow sequentially and so provide the greatest chance of success and therefore persistent progress and direction.  This continually allows both teachers and pupils to live in in an environment of positivity.  And if we explain carefully how the process is working as we are teaching it during lessons, then pupils learn to use the same process in their practice. 

This doesn’t mean that things don’t go wrong from time to time, however careful we (or our pupils) are in setting up the next thing to do.  Maybe a pupil struggles (in a lesson or practice) to get something technical to work or can’t quite figure out a musical point.  

IMG_8514 AMAZON.jpg

I’d like to suggest a way to deal with this, and I call it the Double O Mindset.

So often, musicians and others who find they can’t do things, get annoyed and frustrated: “I CAN’T do this” or maybe “Why CAN’T I do this?” they inwardly scream. This often leads to the follow-up thought: “I’m no good,” or worse, “I’m useless.” 

Of course, it’s entirely the wrong reaction; the wrong response. Rather than this aggressive, subjective, and angry riposte, teach pupils (and ourselves if we need to) to go for the Double O Mindset:

 

Observe and be Objective

In other words, we quietly observe what exactly is going on, and then analyse the situation in an agreeably and peacefully objective manner.

Instead of ranting “Why CAN’T I do this?”

We say, gently and thoughtfully,

Why can’t I do this?

We observe carefully what we are actually doing and we objectively search for a slightly different way that may well simply solve the problem. 

Double O.JPG

The word carefully is important.  When we analyse what we are doing we often don’t delve nearly deep enough.  If it’s technical, try to look, for example, exactly at hand position, use of all muscles involved in the task, exactly at what is being done in relation to the intended outcome.   If it’s musical, is there something not quite understood in the sequence of thought required to be at that particular point.  If our pupil takes this view, they may well solve the problem or realise what it is they don’t get, and bring that with them to the next lesson when, together, we can solve it.

 

So, do consider the Double O Mindset:  Observe and be Objective. It may well save a lot of time and emotional and misdirected negative energy.

Thoughts on the Virtuoso Teacher

I much enjoyed my short visit to Scotland a few weeks ago to do a Virtuoso Teacher Day at the University of Aberdeen under the auspices of the ISM. It’s always wonderful to meet a group of lively and committed teachers and, as usual with these days, many interesting topics were aired and discussed.  


Of course the central theme of the day was the concept of The Virtuoso Teacher. And as our society seems to become more and more disinterested in serious culture, it becomes increasingly important that we aspire to Virtuoso Teacher status. Or, in other words, aspire to teaching at the highest level in order to keep more of our pupils on board and inspired to go out there and be musically independent. 

"Teaching is about sharing"


What exactly do I mean by teaching at the highest level you may be wondering? It’s certainly very challenging trying to sum it up in a few words or in a single point or two (you’ll have to come to one of the VT days to get the whole picture!). And it’s got nothing to do with the level of our pupils. But if pushed, I would say this: teaching at the highest level is strongly connected with the necessity to teach with a generous, big- and open-hearted spirit. Teaching is about sharing. Of course we know more than our pupils. And we can do things a lot better than they can. But teaching is essentially a sharing experience… sharing our love and enthusiasm for music, sharing our deeply considered views on the music we teach and thus helping our pupils in turn to love and share their music. If we can pass this on, humbly and without ego, we have got a chance to help humanity remain cultured. For without culture, humanity becomes dry, cold and meaningless. This, in essence, is what being a Virtuoso Teacher is. 

A sunny day in Aberdeen for the Virtuoso Teacher talk with the ISM. 

A sunny day in Aberdeen for the Virtuoso Teacher talk with the ISM. 

Talking to teachers about the Virtuoso Teacher in Aberdeen. 

Talking to teachers about the Virtuoso Teacher in Aberdeen. 

News from Denmark and thoughts for a productive new term

Following my tour of South Africa, I’m just back from a wonderful visit to the “happiest country in the world”, Denmark, presenting teaching workshops, giving a recital and working with young players. Wherever I go in the world, there are two things I can always rely on: the unqualified enthusiasm of young learners and the reflective and thoughtful enthusiasm of their teachers. 

Our aim in life should always be to make things better. Through our music, it should be to refine and develop our own playing or singing and to guide our pupils to develop theirs. To do this we all, teachers and students alike, simply need to open our minds. We need to minimise the ego and allow ourselves to re-evaluate our methods with unconditional honesty.  

That will be at the heart of the fourteen insets I’m about to embark on as the new academic year gets under way. I shall be talking about Simultaneous Learning, Group Teaching, Being a Virtuoso Teacher, Teaching in the Digital Age, and much more.  I hope we may meet during these next two weeks. 

Whether we do or not, I hope 2016/17 is a great year for you.  Let’s do our best to transcend any problems, enjoy our music making and teaching and try to inspire others with what we are doing! 

 

Teaching in Copenhagen, August 2016

Teaching in Copenhagen, August 2016